Unable to make Mummichog work in functional analysis

Hi all,

I am trying to perform a functional analysis on a set of data comparing 15 control vs 10 LBW samples. I have tried both Mummichog and GSEA, but only GSEA produces any results of significance; Mummichog only produces results where p=1.0 (there will be a popup saying “Possible causes of error (last one being the most relevant): No significant features were found based on the current cutoff! Please adjust the p-value threshold.”

Is there a reason why there is such a huge difference between the two algorithms, and how do I fix my data so that Mummichog produces results that are not all p=1.0.

Test.csv (201.7 KB)

Thank you in advance!

------Functional analysis parameter------
Upload - Functional Analysis
A Peak Intensity Table
Ion Mode: Negative Mode
Mass Tolerance: 5.0
Retention time: Yes-minutes
Data Source: Generic
Data Format: Samples in columns
Data File: See file attached

Filtering: None

Sample normalisation: None
Data transformation: Log transformation
Data scaling: None

Mummichog
Algorithms: Mummichog 2.0, version 2.0
Visual analytics: Scatter plot
Pathway library: Homo sapiens (human) [MFN]
Only use pathways / metabolite sets containing at least 3 entries

GSEA
Algorithms: GSEA 2.0, version 2.0
Visual analytics: Scatter plot
Pathway library: Homo sapiens (human) [MFN]
Only use pathways / metabolite sets containing at least 3 entries